On the forty-second page of “The Civil War as a Theological Crisis”
Notre Dame professor & historian
Mark A. Noll wrote (emphasis added):
of the Bible almost never found support in the South and only
rarely among Northern moderates and conservatives. In general, it
was a use that suffered particular difficulties when, as in the ground
rules laid down for Blanchard and Rice in their Cincinnati
debate, disputants pledged themselves in good Protestant fashion
to base what they said on the Bible as their only authoritative
source.21
Harriet Beecher Stowe's lightning-rod novel, Uncle Tom's
Cabin, provided one of the era's most powerful examples of the
abolitionist appeal to the general spirit of the Bible. The question
of the Bible and slavery appeared repeatedly in the novel, which was
serialized in 1851 and then published to great acclaim (and scorn)
the next year. Stowe, herself a dedicated if romantic partisan for the
Bible, nonetheless subtly queried widespread American notions about
the self-interpreting power of Scripture. For example, she had one of
her slave-owning characters, Augustine St. Clare, suggest that scriptural
interpretation was driven more by interest than intellect: "Suppose
that something should bring down the price of cotton once and forever,
and make the whole slave property a drug in the market, don't you think
we would have another version of the Scripture doctrine? What a flood
of light would pour into the church, all at once, and how immediately
it would be discovered that everything in the Bible and reason went
the other way!"22
Stowe also intimated the cynical conclusion, which would become
more common among secularists after the Civil War, that the Bible was
easily manipulated to prove anything with regard to a problem like
slavery that readers might desire. "Honest old John Van Trompe,"
with an instinctive objection to slavery, long had kept himself at
arms' length from church because of ministers who claimed that
Scripture sanctioned the institution. But when he found experts on
the other side who could use Greek and Hebrew to attack slavery
as effectively as others had used such knowledge to defend it,
Van Trompe, in Stowe's dialogue, "took right hold, and jined the
church."23 At another place in the novel, Stowe had
passangers on a steamboat, which was carrying slaves down the Ohio
River, exchange biblical texts with each other like bird shot. On
the one side: "'It's undoubtedly the intention of Providence
that the African race should be servants—kept in a low
condition,' said a grave-looking gentleman in black, a clergyman,
seated by the cabin door. '"Cursed be Canaan: a servant of servants
shall he be," the scripture says.'" On the other side: "A tall,
slender young man, with a face of expressive of great
More information about “The Civil War as a Theological Crisis” (and the
book itself) is available from:
(University of North Carolina Press, April 2006.
Hardcover, 216 pages.
ISBN: 0807830127; EAN: 9780807830123.)